Politics
Court faults Atiku’s bid to introduce new evidence in Tinubu NYSC eligibility suit
The Federal High Court in Abuja on Friday dismissed an application by Atiku Abubakar, former Vice-President, to introduce additional evidence and particulars of alleged fraud in his suit challenging President Bola Tinubu’s eligibility for the 2027 presidential election.
Justice Inyang Ekwo dismissed the application filed by Atiku and the African Democratic Congress (ADC) to amend their originating summons against Tinubu, the All Progressives Congress (APC) and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), ruling that it lacked merit.
The judge agreed with the defendants that the proposed amendments sought to introduce new facts and allegations of fraud after parties had joined issues, rather than merely correct errors in the original court processes.
Justice Ekwo observed that while the original suit contained no allegation of fraud, the proposed amended originating summons sought to introduce particulars of alleged fraud, additional documents and a written deposition by Atiku.
He held that granting the application would change the character of the case and would not serve the interest of justice.
The judge said pre-election cases, being sui generis actions, do not allow litigants to institute proceedings and subsequently search for evidence to support their claims.
He explained that such cases belong to a class of their own and are governed by specific procedural requirements under the Federal High Court’s Pre-Election Practice Directions.
Justice Ekwo also observed that the plaintiffs failed to controvert assertions in the separate counter-affidavits filed by Tinubu and INEC opposing the application.
He said Atiku and ADC ought to have withdrawn the application after the defendants raised objections to the proposed amendments.
“I made an order dismissing it on the grounds that the averment in Paragraph 9 of the plaintiffs is meant to mislead the court,” the judge ruled.
The court adjourned the substantive suit until December 2 for hearing.
Atiku and ADC had approached the court seeking an order compelling INEC to remove Tinubu and APC from the list of candidates and political parties for the 2027 presidential election over allegations concerning the president’s National Youth Service Corps (NYSC) discharge certificate.
In the suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1888/2026, the plaintiffs alleged that APC submitted a forged NYSC discharge certificate to INEC on behalf of Tinubu.
They asked the court to disqualify the president and the ruling party from participating in the 2027 presidential election.
Following the filing of counter-affidavits by the defendants, Atiku and ADC filed an application on September 10 seeking permission to amend their originating summons.
The applicants said they had identified errors in the description of documents attached to their affidavit, particularly the reference to Form CF001 instead of Form EC9A.
They also sought to provide particulars of the alleged fraud, introduce a written deposition by Atiku and attach clearer copies of documents referenced in their original filing.
The plaintiffs maintained that the proposed amendments were intended to correct errors and improve the presentation of their case. They insisted that they were not introducing new issues or seeking additional reliefs.
Tinubu opposed the application, arguing that the proposed amendments went beyond correcting errors in the description of documents and would alter the case initially brought against him.
In a counter-affidavit deposed to by Moses Adoga, a litigation support officer in the law firm of Wole Olanipekun, SAN, the president argued that Atiku sought to introduce new questions for determination, additional reliefs and documents.
Adoga said the proposed amendments would introduce an entirely new relief and additional paragraphs in the supporting affidavit, thereby altering the substance of the original proceedings.
He also challenged the competence of the substantive suit, arguing that it was statute-barred because it was filed on August 14, while the cause of action arose on July 11, when Tinubu’s name was submitted to INEC.
According to him, the 1999 Constitution, as amended, prescribes the timeframe for instituting pre-election cases, and the court’s practice directions cannot extend the constitutionally prescribed period.
He further argued that Atiku’s attempt to introduce particulars of alleged fraud amounted to an admission that the original originating summons lacked the particulars required to sustain the claim.
Tinubu and APC denied submitting any forged NYSC certificate to INEC for either the 2023 or 2027 presidential elections.
In their joint counter-affidavit filed on September 9, they maintained that the NYSC had never denied issuing the discharge certificate to the president at the end of his service year.
Through APC’s Director of Legal Services, Sanusi Samaila, they argued that proving the forgery of a certificate required a disclaimer from the institution said to have issued it. They cited a previous Supreme Court decision in support of their position.
They urged the court to dismiss the substantive suit on the grounds that it was incompetent and that the plaintiffs lacked locus standi to institute the action.
INEC also challenged the competence of the suit, citing statute of limitation, lack of locus standi, absence of a reasonable cause of action and abuse of court process.
In opposing the amendment application, the commission argued that the proposed changes would introduce a fresh cause of action or cure jurisdictional defects after the expiration of the 14-day period prescribed under Section 285(9) of the Constitution for instituting pre-election matters.
The commission also maintained that the plaintiffs failed to comply with the written deposition requirements under Paragraph 7(1) of the Federal High Court Pre-Election Practice Directions (Amendment) 2026.
The substantive suit remains pending, with the defendants’ preliminary objections challenging its competence yet to be determined.
-
Business19 hours agoKola Karim’s $10bn ambition: Building Nigeria’s answer to Tata
-
News19 hours agoConstitutional lawyer alleges breach, heads to court to block State Police
-
Business19 hours agoNaira slides to N1440/$ as foreign reserves shed $406m
-
Opinion18 hours agoLiving in bondage: Jimmy Odukoya and Lara Adeboye
-
News19 hours agoFG suspends Lagos-Ibadan bridge work after 20-hour gridlock
-
Politics2 hours agoAngry mob attacks Rarara, Tinubu’s praise singer, at National Mosque, Abuja
-
Business19 hours agoHow Dangote’s highway spend de-risks his $14.3bn refinery expansion
-
Business19 hours agoAnthropic opens 35 percent above IPO price as shares debut at $111.99
